Controversy Surrounding Yasuke in Assassin’s Creed Shadows
Ubisoft Apologizes to Japanese Fans
The development team behind Assassin’s Creed Shadows has issued an apology for elements in the game’s promotional materials that have caused discomfort among some Japanese fans. Released via social media in both English and Japanese, Ubisoft’s statement acknowledged the concerns but did not specify exactly what had sparked the controversy. The game, which is set to launch on November 15, will “keep evolving” according to the statement. The apology particularly addressed the depiction of Yasuke, a historic Black samurai, whose portrayal as one of the game’s main protagonists has been a point of contention.
Yasuke – A Historical Debate
Yasuke’s life is shrouded in mystery and characterized by limited historical records. Known to have served under the powerful Japanese warlord Oda Nobunaga, Yasuke’s fate after Nobunaga’s death is largely unknown. Historian Yu Hirayama has gone on record via Twitter to affirm Yasuke’s status as a samurai, adding depth to the heated discussions.
Sparking Curiosity or Fostering Contention?
Although the game is set during Japan’s Sengoku or Warring States period, it incorporates significant creative liberties. Ubisoft stated that Assassin’s Creed games, from their inception, have blended historical events with fictional elements to create immersive experiences. However, this approach has not been well-received by some Japanese fans who argue that Yasuke’s portrayal as a legendary samurai is historically inaccurate. The concerns also extend to promotional materials, which have included imprecise depictions of Japanese culture and artifacts.
Apology and Assurance from Ubisoft
“Some elements in our promotional materials have caused concern within the Japanese community,” reads a part of the statement, adding: “For this, we sincerely apologize.” Ubisoft assured fans that the game is still in development and will continue to evolve based on constructive criticism. The company maintains that while it strives for authenticity, the ultimate goal is to create a compelling and entertaining video game.
Creative Liberties and Historical Advisers
“While we strive for authenticity in everything we do, Assassin’s Creed games are works of fiction inspired by real historical events and figures.” – Ubisoft
Historical Accuracy vs. Creative Freedom
Ubisoft emphasized that its creative decisions are made to enhance gameplay and entertainment, even when these decisions spark debate. The company highlighted its collaboration with external consultants, historians, and internal teams at Ubisoft Japan but clarified that these collaborators were not responsible for the ultimate decisions made in the game’s development.
Respect for Japanese Heritage
Ubisoft’s statement emphasized respect for Japanese history and culture, acknowledging the passionate responses from Japanese fans. The game’s other protagonist, Naoe, a Japanese shinobi, provides a contrasting gameplay style that also aims to capture the essence of Feudal Japan. Ubisoft encourages respectful feedback from fans, reinforcing that the team’s collective goal is to celebrate the rich tapestry of Japanese history while creating an engaging gaming experience.
Backlash from Experts
In addition to the general public, experts have weighed in on the controversy. Japanese historian Yu Hirayama and others have contested the portrayal of Yasuke, adding that the depiction of a brutal, village-striding Yasuke does not align with the historical image of a samurai. Ubisoft has responded by apologizing and committing to removing certain artwork after backlash over unauthorized usage of particular symbols.
Bridging Fantasy and Reality
In the gaming world, blending historical realism with fantasy elements is not new to the Assassin’s Creed series. However, striking the right balance is often challenging. For Assassin’s Creed Shadows, the inclusion of a Black samurai in the heart of Feudal Japan has opened up dialogues, albeit heated, about representation, accuracy, and creative freedom. Whether this backlash will affect the game’s reception at launch remains to be seen.
Conclusion
As Assassin’s Creed Shadows approaches its release date, Ubisoft’s willingness to address fans’ concerns and adapt creative elements in response demonstrates a commitment to a respectful and historically conscious approach. While the debate surrounding Yasuke’s portrayal highlights larger issues of historical representation in popular media, it also underscores the potential for games to inspire deeper exploration of history and culture. Whether Ubisoft’s efforts will appease critics or fuel further controversy will ultimately be judged by the players come November.
Mehek